This message delayed because of communications breakdown; thoughts still valid…
Fears and doubts, couched in terms of cynicism and the old fin-de-siÃ¨cle blues, may truly be set aside after last weekâ€™s Philharmonic event at Disney Hall. Our young maestro has earned his spurs not so much with another whoop-de-doo orchestral Saturnalia but with a much-loved, subtle masterwork as much known for eliciting tears as cheers. The outburst of silence that Gustavo Dudamel drew from the capacity crowd last Thursday after his performance of Schubertâ€™s â€œUnfinishedâ€ Symphony spoke as eloquently as any juncture loud or soft along this thoroughly satisfactory musicianâ€™s mercurial rise to fame. What a great night of music-making!â€¦ and what music!
What is there about this B-minor half-symphony, this enchanted Â relic, that stands it apart from the rest of the worldâ€™s trove of abandoned beauty? Its story makes for good p-r: the hand of God signaling â€œenoughâ€ to its suffering composer; Schubert himself realizing that that he had taken musical language past a boundary that noone had previously crossed, realizing (justifiably) that the world wasnâ€™t yet ready for him. The orchestral language â€“ trombones especially â€“ proclaims sonorities that only Richard Wagner, decades later, would attempt. The harmonies â€“ just take the spine-chilling sequence that ends the slow movement in a radiant dark luminescence â€“ still resonate as â€œtypically Schubertianâ€ because nobody has tried them since.
The considerable legacy of â€œunfinishedâ€ Schubert forms a tantalizing bundle of scribbled pages, yellowed half-sheets of whole symphonies, separate orchestral movements, along with piano sonatas, chamber works Â and songs. When I was a lad Â the world acknowledged seven Schubert symphonies; now there are ten, with the newly discovered Â â€œTenthâ€ looming Â large on last weekâ€™s Dudamel program. It is a three-movement work, broad and oratorical in style. Its manuscript dates from 1828, Schubertâ€™s last year. Its first movement starts with welcoming fanfares, shading off to a second theme nearly as gorgeous as its counterpart in the â€œUnfinishedâ€ (â€œThis is, the Sym-pho-neeâ€ etc.) Its slow movement is a long and haunting nocturne; one recent critic describes it, quite accurately, as a reminiscence of Schubert Â being remembered by Gustav Mahler, and that is accurate. The British scholar Brian Newbould has made these fragments into full symphonies, or single symphonic movements, a legacy of genuine Schubertian beauty where none existed before. Â Dudamelâ€™s program included two â€œdemummifyingâ€ ventures by Italyâ€™s master-meddler Luciano Berio, both quite marvelous: one a, the other Berioâ€™s Â â€œRenderingâ€ of this â€œSchubert Tenth,â€ and a gathering with small ensemble of old-timey folksongs â€“ such, for example, as the evergreen â€œBlack, Black, Blackâ€ set for solo singer (angelic Dawn Upshaw).
The Schubert fragments, the elegant oratory of a genius literally on his deathbed, shade off into cloudy, dreamlike response in Berioâ€™s light-textured counterpoint. Their linkage forces a dialog of styles across a century. Oddly enough, it works; the long Schubertian fagments stop the breath with their dusky beauty, while the Berio ripostes Â maintain their own distinctive â€œcommentary.â€
For the ensuing magical evening of Purcell the walls of Disney Hall seemed to close in and impinge upon our imagination. Four centuries later, the dramatic intensity of Dido and Aeneas is undiminished. The flights of harmonic and melodic daring, the dissonances — the cross-relations that pit, say, an F-sharp against an F-natural, the sudden wrenching modulation, a jagged melodic line out of nowhere â€“ all these proclaim the lasting power of this amazing-if-arrogant British genius. From Susan Grahamâ€™s delivery of Didoâ€™s first words of lamentation â€“ â€œAh, Belinda, I am pressâ€™dâ€¦â€ to her electrifying final imploring â€“ â€œRemember me, but Ah! Forget my fateâ€¦â€ that joyous hall seemed sucked dry by tragedy irresistibly delivered, the needle-pricks of the strings of Nichola McGeganâ€™s Â Philharmonia Baroque visiting Â from Berkeley.
Graham, whom I had mostly heard in bel-canto and other Rossinian hi-jinks, delivered haunting, arching vocal lines with a fine command of vocal color, and with the strength to control coloration at an amazing range of vocal strength. I love looking at her tall, commanding good looks, and Â I love the broad range of her vocal strengths. We need her here.
AND WHILE WEâ€™RE ON THE SUBJECT OF PHENOMENALLY TALENTED RED-HEADS:
At long last weâ€™ve had a full-length Piano Spheres recital by LAâ€™s own Eric Huebner, whose coiffure suggests that his splendid brain-case may be aflame both inside and out. A Juilliard kid –among other accomplishments– he has made local jaws drop with his Messaien exploits, among others. At Zipper Hall he honored California teachers including Roger Reynolds of UC-San Diego. Dan Rothman of CalArts, Chen Yi and George Tsontakis from all around. I particularly admired the Tsontakis Ghost Variations, a big piano panoramas that sounded notes of grandeur Â that awoke comparisons to Lisztian transcendental etudes, before settling back upon a paraphase of a Mozartian concerto finale (the grand and spacious K. 482).
I admire this brilliant young musician; heâ€™s on his way. Along with the best of his generation, he fills the space of his â€œsphere.â€